top of page

50+ Homemade Ice Cream Flavors Rotating in Centerville, TN

Owner Concetta West has created more than 50 unique ice cream flavors since we opened, and she's still developing new ones. At any time, 18 flavors fill our display case at the downtown cafe. Some are classics that customers would riot over if we removed them. Others rotate through as they sell out, making room for new creations or returning favorites.

 

Every flavor is made by hand in small batches at our Highway 100 production kitchen. Real ingredients, no shortcuts, genuine small-batch quality. That's why each flavor tastes like what it's supposed to taste like, not a chemical approximation.

​​

Call (931) 729-3481 | cafe@thelocalplacetn.com
111 S Public Square, Centerville, TN 37033

Our Ice Cream Flavor Selection

Some flavors have earned permanent status. Customers count on finding these whenever they visit. They're the foundation of our ice cream menu, the ones that made us famous, the flavors people drive an hour to get.

Scooping homemade bubble gum flavor ice cream The LOCAL Place Centerville TN

Rotating Specialty Flavors

Beyond the classics, we rotate through dozens of specialty flavors. When one sells out, another takes its place. This keeps things interesting for regular customers and gives us room to experiment with new creations. Some specialty flavors are seasonal. Others are experiments that become permanent if customers love them enough.

​

​Classic flavors like Chocolate, Vanilla, Pecan Praline, Cookies & Cream, Banana Pudding and Strawberry are normally stocked, unless they have sold out. See our list of flavors for other specialty flavors

Concetta West with mystery flavor ice cream cone LOCAL Place Centerville cafe

Mystery Flavor - Changes Without Warning

One spot in our case is always unlabeled. The mystery flavor changes without warning, sometimes daily. It might be a new creation we're testing. It might be a returning favorite. It might be something completely wild. The only way to know is to ask our staff or just be brave and try it blind. Mystery flavor fans treat it like a game, coming in specifically to guess what's in the unlabeled container.

Ice cream case with three homemade flavors The LOCAL Place cafe Centerville TN

How Our Ice Cream Is Made

Every batch starts with Concetta sourcing quality ingredients. Real fruits, real chocolate, real vanilla. No artificial flavoring shortcuts. She makes each batch at our Highway 100 production facility using small-batch techniques. The equipment is larger than home ice cream makers, but the process and attention to quality is the same as making it in your kitchen. That's why the texture is smooth, the flavors are intense, and each scoop tastes like someone actually cared about making it. Because someone did.

This is what sets us apart.  Owner Concetta West hand-making bubble gum pieces from scratch before even starting the ice cream base. Every bit of detail goes into our ice cream. No shortcuts, no artificial ingredients, just genuine small-batch craftsmanship that you can taste in every scoop.

Pints of homemade ice cream lobby display freezer LOCAL Place Centerville cafe

Available by the Scoop, Pint, or for Catering

Get your ice cream however you want it. Single scoops in a cup, sugar cone, cake cone, or fresh-made waffle cone. Pints to take home and enjoy at your own pace. Or catering quantities for your next event. We can prepare special batches with advance notice for birthday parties, weddings, corporate events, and more. Just call to discuss what you need.

Some of Our Handmade Ice Cream Flavors

Every flavor is made by hand in small batches at our Highway 100 production facility. We rotate selections regularly, so what's available changes throughout the week. Here is a List of some of the flavors we make.  Call ahead at (931) 729-3481 if you're looking for something specific, or stop by to see what's currently in the case.

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Strawberry

  • Blueberry

  • Wildberry

  • Cheesecake

  • Zonkers

  • Bees Knees

  • Lemmon Velvet

  • ​Loaded Sweet Potato

  • Banana Pudding

  • Pecan Prailine

  • Jimmy Carter

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Cinnamon Toast

  • Death By Chocolate

  • Dubai Chocolate

  • Rocky Road

  • Buttermint Chip

  • ​Caramel Apple

  • Thickmint

  • Bubblegum

  • Cotton Candy

  • Maple Walnut

  • Black Currant

  • Passionfruit

  • Peach

  • Pumpkin Pie

  • Lemon Bar

  • ​Cinnamon Bun

  • Strawberry Lemonade

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry

  • Jimmy Carter

  • Monkey Around

  • Butterscotch Swirl

  • Brown Sugar Bourbon

  • Salted Caramel

  • Caramel Macchiato

  • Speakeasy

  • Black Licorice

  • Cookie Monster

  • Key Lime Pie

  • Mocha Almond Fudge

  • Matcha

  • Arnold Palmer

  • Coconut Curry Cashew

  • Strawberry Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • Maple Bacon

Flavors FAQ's
bottom of page